Roanoke College

Keating was standout on both the lacrosse and soccer fields during his time at Roanoke. In lacrosse he was named a USILA All-American on three occasions, including two first-team selections. As a senior he was named the USILA Division III National Player of the Year as well as the National Midfielder of the Year.

A three-time First-Team All-ODAC selection, he earned ODAC Player of the Years honors in 2006 to go along with a selection to the USILA North-South All-Star game and a spot on the USILA Scholar All-American Squad. Keating led RC to back-to-back ODAC Championship game and NCAA Final Four appearances in 2005 and 2006. On the soccer pitch, Keating was named NSCAA All-Atlantic Region as a senior in 2005 and a two-time First-Team All-ODAC selection during his career. He helped the Maroons to the 2004 ODAC Championship and spot in the NCAA Tournament.